The impact of working together with classmates on feedback in architectural model making can be tricky. There are some challenges that can make this process less effective. Let’s look at some of these challenges:
-
Subjectivity of Feedback:
- When classmates give critiques, their opinions can vary a lot. This means that feedback can sometimes be confusing or even contradicting. Students might not know whose advice to follow.
-
Varying Skill Levels:
- Some students have more experience than others. This can lead to stronger students taking over discussions. As a result, less experienced students might not share their ideas, which can reduce the variety of feedback and make some feel left out.
-
Groupthink Phenomenon:
- When working in groups, people might feel pressure to agree with the loudest voices instead of sharing their true thoughts. This can hurt the learning experience and make it hard for students to think for themselves.
-
Time Constraints:
- Working together often takes more time than giving individual feedback. In a busy studio, this can be an issue. As a result, students may rush through discussions, which could lead to less helpful feedback.
Potential Solutions:
- To solve these problems, we can hold structured feedback sessions. This means setting clear rules for how to give critiques, which can help make feedback less subjective.
- Also, providing training on how to give good feedback can help everyone share better ideas.
- Lastly, encouraging a culture where constructive criticism is valued, and respecting different viewpoints can help reduce groupthink. This makes for a better feedback environment for everyone involved.