Some people believe that judicial review gives too much power to the Supreme Court. Here are some reasons why:
Unelected Judges: Supreme Court justices are chosen, not voted for. This means they can make big decisions about laws and policies without getting input from the public. Many wonder if it's fair for just a few people to have this much power.
Judicial Activism: Some justices might practice something called judicial activism. This means they interpret the Constitution based on their own beliefs instead of what the original authors meant. This can cause surprising rulings that change laws in unexpected ways.
Checks and Balances: Judicial review can mess up the balance of power among different parts of the government. If the Supreme Court often strikes down laws made by Congress or state governments, it can hurt how those laws are made.
Limited Accountability: Even though justices can be removed from their position, they usually serve for life. They don't have to worry about public opinion like elected officials do. This can lead to decisions that don't represent what most people want.
In summary, many worry that a small group of justices, who aren't directly accountable to the people, have too much influence over important laws and policies. This sometimes goes against the idea of democracy.
Some people believe that judicial review gives too much power to the Supreme Court. Here are some reasons why:
Unelected Judges: Supreme Court justices are chosen, not voted for. This means they can make big decisions about laws and policies without getting input from the public. Many wonder if it's fair for just a few people to have this much power.
Judicial Activism: Some justices might practice something called judicial activism. This means they interpret the Constitution based on their own beliefs instead of what the original authors meant. This can cause surprising rulings that change laws in unexpected ways.
Checks and Balances: Judicial review can mess up the balance of power among different parts of the government. If the Supreme Court often strikes down laws made by Congress or state governments, it can hurt how those laws are made.
Limited Accountability: Even though justices can be removed from their position, they usually serve for life. They don't have to worry about public opinion like elected officials do. This can lead to decisions that don't represent what most people want.
In summary, many worry that a small group of justices, who aren't directly accountable to the people, have too much influence over important laws and policies. This sometimes goes against the idea of democracy.