Click the button below to see similar posts for other categories

Why Was the Virginia Plan Controversial During the Convention?

The Virginia Plan created a lot of discussions during the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Here are some of the main reasons why:

  1. Representation: The plan suggested that the number of representatives in Congress should depend on how many people lived in each state. This meant that bigger states would have more power. For example, Virginia had about 700,000 people, so it would have more say than smaller states like Delaware, which only had around 60,000 people.

  2. Two Houses of Congress: The Virginia Plan wanted to create two groups in Congress. This idea worried smaller states because they thought larger states would have too much power over decisions.

  3. National Power vs. State Power: The plan wanted a stronger national government, which could take away some power from individual states. Many people were scared that this could lead to unfair control like what they experienced under British rule.

  4. Debates and Solutions: All these arguments led to lots of debates and discussions. In the end, they came up with a compromise called the Connecticut Compromise. This plan established two houses in Congress but made sure that every state has equal representation in the Senate, no matter how big or small they are.

Related articles

Similar Categories
Colonization for Grade 9 US HistoryIndependence for Grade 9 US HistoryThe American Revolution for Grade 9 US HistoryThe Constitution for Grade 9 US HistoryCivil War Era for Grade 10 US HistoryReconstruction Era for Grade 10 US HistoryRenaissance for Grade 10 World HistoryModern America for Grade 11 US HistoryCivil Rights Movement for Grade 11 US History20th Century America for Grade 11 US HistoryAmerican Colonization for Grade 11 AP US HistoryModern Era for Grade 12 US HistoryCivil Rights Movement for Grade 12 US HistoryGlobal Influence for Grade 12 AP US HistoryBritish History for Year 10 History (GCSE Year 1)World History for Year 10 History (GCSE Year 1)British History for Year 11 History (GCSE Year 2)World History for Year 11 History (GCSE Year 2)British History for Year 12 History (AS-Level)World History for Year 12 History (AS-Level)British History for Year 13 History (A-Level)World History for Year 13 History (A-Level)Sweden's History for Year 7 HistoryWorld History for Year 7 HistorySweden's History for Year 8 HistoryWorld History for Year 8 HistorySweden's History for Year 9 HistoryWorld History for Year 9 HistorySweden's History for Gymnasium Year 1 HistoryWorld History for Gymnasium Year 1 HistorySwedish History for Gymnasium Year 2 HistoryGlobal History for Gymnasium Year 2 HistoryEras of Western Civilization for History of Western CivilizationInfluential Figures in Western Civilization for History of Western CivilizationAncient Egyptian CivilizationAncient Roman CivilizationAncient Chinese CivilizationWorld War IWorld War IIThe Cold WarMahatma GandhiMartin Luther King Jr.CleopatraArt Movements Through HistoryReligions and Their InfluenceFashion Through the AgesCivil Rights MovementFeminist MovementsEnvironmental MovementKey Inventions Through HistoryFamous Scientists and Their ContributionsThe Evolution of Technology
Click HERE to see similar posts for other categories

Why Was the Virginia Plan Controversial During the Convention?

The Virginia Plan created a lot of discussions during the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Here are some of the main reasons why:

  1. Representation: The plan suggested that the number of representatives in Congress should depend on how many people lived in each state. This meant that bigger states would have more power. For example, Virginia had about 700,000 people, so it would have more say than smaller states like Delaware, which only had around 60,000 people.

  2. Two Houses of Congress: The Virginia Plan wanted to create two groups in Congress. This idea worried smaller states because they thought larger states would have too much power over decisions.

  3. National Power vs. State Power: The plan wanted a stronger national government, which could take away some power from individual states. Many people were scared that this could lead to unfair control like what they experienced under British rule.

  4. Debates and Solutions: All these arguments led to lots of debates and discussions. In the end, they came up with a compromise called the Connecticut Compromise. This plan established two houses in Congress but made sure that every state has equal representation in the Senate, no matter how big or small they are.

Related articles